I was curious if I can get any activity from a bundle of ferrocerium fire starter rods. I have had these for about 10-15 years, the source was IIRC ebay, and the very likely origin China.
I expected these to have at least some trace of Lu-176 with its peaks at 202 and 307keV, and the below spectrogram seems to confirm this.
There are also a number of other peaks and I am not sure what produces those.
This was taken using as source a plastic bag containing about 400g ferrocerium rods.
Setup:
1. Hardware:
-GS-2020-CSI detector, 2x2in CsI(Tl) crystal
-GS-USB-PRO MCA
-shield: 4cm thick lead castle lined on the inside with 2 layers of 1.5mm each copper sheet
2. Software:
-Artix Linux
-PRA 2.5 running under system wine
3. Settings:
-1300V
-volume 130%
-acquisition time 1800s
4. Calibration:
-5-point slope fit using the peaks of Lu-176(LYSO crystal) at 202 and 307keV; Cs-137 commercial source (662keV); Co-60 commercial source (1173 and 1332keV
-background radiation (1800s) was subtracted
Result:
I have annotated the peaks I can see with numbers and approximate energies.
peak 1 is likely the copper lining XRF
peak 3 is likely some residual lead XRF
peaks 4 and 6 are likely the Lu-176 characteristic emissions.
peak 9 is the K-40
I am not sure what peaks 2, 5, 7, 8, 10 and 11 are. Especially peak 8 is interesting as it is rather dominant.
All values are approximate, especially outside the 202-1332keV range where my calibration sources lie.
NORM: ferrocerium fire starter rods, and help needed to identify peaks
-
stamasd
- Posts: 124
- Joined: 29 Oct 2017, 02:12
NORM: ferrocerium fire starter rods, and help needed to identify peaks
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
-
Svilen
- Posts: 202
- Joined: 23 Sep 2016, 04:25
Re: NORM: ferrocerium fire starter rods, and help needed to identify peaks
In such a mixture of rare-earth elements, these weak lines can overlap and the identification is more than uncertain. There can be traces of Th and U-chain activity and Pb-214 is a possible candidate for peak 7 for example. You need a longer acquisition I think.
Peak 8 looks like Cs-137, but it is not really expected to be there I guess. Maybe you can repeat the measurement with the sample farther from the detector - a Cs-137 peak should rather keep its energy and fall more slowly with distance, while a possible sum peak could decrease more rapidly...
Peak 8 looks like Cs-137, but it is not really expected to be there I guess. Maybe you can repeat the measurement with the sample farther from the detector - a Cs-137 peak should rather keep its energy and fall more slowly with distance, while a possible sum peak could decrease more rapidly...
-
stamasd
- Posts: 124
- Joined: 29 Oct 2017, 02:12
Re: NORM: ferrocerium fire starter rods, and help needed to identify peaks
Good ideas. I will repeat this with a 2h acquisition time, once for the background and once for the sample.
My lead castle isn't that large, but I think I can make a 10cm separation between the sample and the detector. Maybe even 15cm.
My lead castle isn't that large, but I think I can make a 10cm separation between the sample and the detector. Maybe even 15cm.
-
stamasd
- Posts: 124
- Joined: 29 Oct 2017, 02:12
Re: NORM: ferrocerium fire starter rods, and help needed to identify peaks
Haha, I started taking a 2-h background reading, and when I looked at it after about 1h I realized something was terribly wrong.
It turns out just prior to the ferrocerium experiment I had played with some of the settings, and... I forgot to put one of them back. Specifically the volume was lowered to 100% from 130%. So everything was shifted down. That peak that appeared at 655 keV was in fact K-40 at 1430. :)
I reset everything as it should be and I'm now taking a new background reading, which looks fine this time, and will take a 2-h reading of the ferrocerium after that.
So for the time being please ignore the diagram in the first post.
It turns out just prior to the ferrocerium experiment I had played with some of the settings, and... I forgot to put one of them back. Specifically the volume was lowered to 100% from 130%. So everything was shifted down. That peak that appeared at 655 keV was in fact K-40 at 1430. :)
I reset everything as it should be and I'm now taking a new background reading, which looks fine this time, and will take a 2-h reading of the ferrocerium after that.
So for the time being please ignore the diagram in the first post.
-
stamasd
- Posts: 124
- Joined: 29 Oct 2017, 02:12
Re: NORM: ferrocerium fire starter rods, and help needed to identify peaks
OK here is the _real_ ferrocerium spectrum. All settings the same as in the original post except for acquisition time = 7200s.
With background subtracted: Note that those aren't large counts. The most counts above background for the tallest peaks do not exceed 70-80 pulses per 2h
And without background subtracted: I can kinda see the following:
219keV+311keV, likely Lu-176
270keV
381keV
427keV
543keV
671keV
801keV (the largest peak except the K-40one)
974keV
1125keV
1255keV
1430keV - the K-40
2779keV
2949keV
Note that all energies above are inferred through slope fit, likely imprecise especially at the extremes.
With background subtracted: Note that those aren't large counts. The most counts above background for the tallest peaks do not exceed 70-80 pulses per 2h
And without background subtracted: I can kinda see the following:
219keV+311keV, likely Lu-176
270keV
381keV
427keV
543keV
671keV
801keV (the largest peak except the K-40one)
974keV
1125keV
1255keV
1430keV - the K-40
2779keV
2949keV
Note that all energies above are inferred through slope fit, likely imprecise especially at the extremes.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
-
Svilen
- Posts: 202
- Joined: 23 Sep 2016, 04:25
Re: NORM: ferrocerium fire starter rods, and help needed to identify peaks
Could you please post a picture of the background alone and the activity of the sample?
-
stamasd
- Posts: 124
- Joined: 29 Oct 2017, 02:12
Re: NORM: ferrocerium fire starter rods, and help needed to identify peaks
Here's the background only
I don't have a record of the total counts.
I don't have a record of the total counts.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
-
Svilen
- Posts: 202
- Joined: 23 Sep 2016, 04:25
Re: NORM: ferrocerium fire starter rods, and help needed to identify peaks
I meant that you could measure the counts for one minute with and without the sample in the castle, then calculate the difference to see the activity above background for orientation. In any case, though, the source seems too weak to measure reliably with a CsI detector. Well, we all surely like to explore these limits :)
The only more significant difference than BKG I see is the peak around ~800 keV, but I also don't know what it can be...
The only more significant difference than BKG I see is the peak around ~800 keV, but I also don't know what it can be...
-
stamasd
- Posts: 124
- Joined: 29 Oct 2017, 02:12
Re: NORM: ferrocerium fire starter rods, and help needed to identify peaks
I agreee, close to the limit.
I went back to the raw data files and I was able to extract the following:
background: 64606 total pulses, 16197 filtered pulses (over 7200s)
ferrocerium sample: 69380 total pulses, 17743 filtered pulses (over 7200s)
Not a great difference, low activity sample.
Unfortunately that is my best detector.
I have a larger one - 3x3inch NaI(Tl) from ebay and 3" PMT with homemade divider; unfortunately that crystal was not in great shape from the day I got it and has a poor FWHM therefore I rarely use it, if at all.
I went back to the raw data files and I was able to extract the following:
background: 64606 total pulses, 16197 filtered pulses (over 7200s)
ferrocerium sample: 69380 total pulses, 17743 filtered pulses (over 7200s)
Not a great difference, low activity sample.
Unfortunately that is my best detector.
I have a larger one - 3x3inch NaI(Tl) from ebay and 3" PMT with homemade divider; unfortunately that crystal was not in great shape from the day I got it and has a poor FWHM therefore I rarely use it, if at all.
-
stamasd
- Posts: 124
- Joined: 29 Oct 2017, 02:12
Re: NORM: ferrocerium fire starter rods, and help needed to identify peaks
In retrospect, after posting the spectrum of a chunk of lanthanum metal, the peaks around 800keV and at 1430keV are likely due to lanthanum present (based on the La-138 natural isotope), which is unavoidable as an impurity during the manufacturing process of ferrocerium (in fact they don't make many efforts to keep lanthanum out of the composition, as it functions the same as cerium in those rods and it has no other major application to incentivize its separation).